by Reth » Tue May 01, 2012 1:35 pm
Well, I only bought this game last week, so I can give my genuine first impression without the need of hindsight!
Um, well, honestly my first impression isn't great so far. The premise is humorous, and I like that much, but apart from that the dialogue feels really juvenile and the combat is really nothing special - which isn't good for such a grind heavy game. The dialogue feels like a really kiddy attempt at Disgaea-type humour with a pandering to yuri tension that comes through a bit too strong and simple.
I've been flicking through pages of this forum trying to find an answer to my burning questions, "What's so amazing about this game?" But the only solid answer I can find is cute character designs, and though yeah, I agree with that, I really need a lot more than that to enjoy a game.
I'm only a couple hours in, Nisa has just joined my party, so this really is a first impression. I'm not condemning it yet (Hell, I hated Ar Tonelico 2 when I first started it and now it's my favourite JRPG) - but I'm dubious so far.
Someone, give me a reason to want to keep playing this! There has to be a reason it's so popular!
EDIT- I should specify I'm playing mk2, due to recommendation I skipped the original altogether.

